Opinions are often sharply divided over the question of whether chaplains should teach or not. What do you think?
The question put for this poll was:
Teaching is an essential element of a school chaplain’s role.
The results were closer than I thought they might be.
In posting this poll a number of chaplains said to me that they didn’t like the question. That they didn’t think teaching was essential but that they could see that it is a valuable tool for building relationships and respect with students and teachers.
From time to time I have heard the assertion that ‘chaplains won’t have credibility if they don’t teach’. This is not a position I agree with. Mostly I don’t agree because I have seen chaplains who don’t teach having a profound impact on their school through their pastoral care and community building role. Certainly chaplains who don’t teach need to be more intentional about how they build relationships but this can be a very healthy thing.
On the other hand I have been witness to chaplains near burnout because of the teaching load they carry alongside their other duties.
So I don’t think it is either or…I think chaplains should be able to choose to teach or not depending on their skill set and their desire. However maybe there is a limit to how much a chaplain should teach if they are to have the space to fulfill other roles.
I wonder what you think about this?